Perfect fit, 12/25/2015 12:54:08 AM
By: Marieelena from ME - See all my reviews
I ordered the wrong one to start with and they replaced it for me right away and the one they sent me fit perfectly. Super customer service. Will do business with them again.
This new gasket isn't even close to right., 11/4/2012 10:26:14 PM
By: Karl from AZ - See all my reviews
Lid rattles with new gasket after lock down. The lid fits tighter with old leaky gasket because the old gasket is thicker. New gasket doesn't even have the same profile as the old gasket. Possible packaging error, because these two gaskets aren't even close, except they're both round. I'm sending it back with a piece of the old gasket in hopes Goodman's can get it right.